Purpose/goal: To locate and critically think about the validity of this website by searching through the http://zapatopi.net/treeoctopus website. This will be done by answering the following questions about the Pacific North West Tree Octopus and using other sites to try and validate the content on this page.
Activities/Procedures:
- Go to the the http://zapatopi.net/treeoctopus/ website
- Answer the following questions by navigating the tree octopus page and using 2 different search engines to attempt to validate the information. (i.e. Google, Yahoo, etc.)
Importance of Activity:
- Helps students understand the importance of site validity
- Takes an interactive approach so that your students can learn how to navigate a website and recognize the signs of a poor website.
- Makes them think critically about why this is important when writing a research paper/project
Questions:
- What is the name given for the way the Pacific North West Tree Octopus moves around the trees? Look up this process on two the available search engines. What did you find?
- Look at the list of literature on the media tab of the website. What do all these books seem to have in common? Why is that important to the sites validity?
- Look at the pictures shown on the sightings tab of the website, do these pictures show any sign of validity for the species? Try and look up the pictures on one of the two search engines, what do you notice about the pictures you find? Is there any similarity between what you found on the website?
- What does it say all the way at the bottom of the About page? Why is this important to the sites validity?
1. The process given on the website is called tentaculation. I looked it up using google.com and used dictionary.com to find its meaning. There is no such thing as tentaculation, but the word tentaculate means to have tantacles.
ReplyDelete2. Most of the links to the literature under the media tab seem to point at fiction or speculative science. If the website really wanted to bring awareness to a real species, all, or at least most of the media would include factual information.
4. At the bottom of the About page it says that the website is not affiliated with any university besides the Kelvinic University branch of the Wild Haggis Conservation Society. I looked up this university and on its page it lists all of the academic criteria but does not have any interactive component like any other University's website would have. If the site is only affiliated with a fake university then why should we believe any of the information on the website is valid?